Have you ever wondered why some teams clinch the championship while others can't seem to catch a break? Or why certain businesses skyrocket to success while others fade into obscurity? From the intense battles on the sports field to the high-stakes decisions in corporate boardrooms, strategy is the invisible force that often makes the difference.
We hear it all the time: "They won because the coach's strategy was unbeatable," or "Their business thrived due to a brilliant market strategy." But what exactly is strategy, and why does it play such a pivotal role across so many areas of life—from sports and warfare to business and even board games?
In his compelling book, Good Strategy Bad Strategy, Richard Rumelt demystifies the concept of strategy, revealing why some strategies propel us forward while others hold us back. He argues that while many people talk about strategy, few truly understand what separates a good strategy from a bad one.
In this blog, we'll dive into the heart of Rumelt's insights. We'll explore what makes a strategy effective, why bad strategies are so common, and how you can craft a strategy that not only sounds good on paper but also delivers real-world results. Whether you're a business leader, a coach, or someone looking to make better decisions in life, understanding these principles can be a game-changer.
At its core, a good strategy isn't just about setting lofty goals or dreaming up an inspiring vision. It's about making tough choices and focusing your efforts where they matter most. It's recognizing the challenges ahead and crafting a coherent plan to tackle them head-on.
Too often, organizations chase multiple objectives without a clear focus, spreading resources thin and diluting their impact. Imagine a soccer team where every player tries to be both offense and defense simultaneously—it would be chaos! Similarly, a good strategy requires prioritizing what's most important and aligning your resources accordingly.
One of the key elements of a good strategy is the ability to identify your unique strengths and use them to your advantage, all while being aware of your competitors' weaknesses.
Example: Sam Walton's Wal-Mart
Consider how Sam Walton built Wal-Mart into a retail giant. He saw an opportunity in small, rural towns that big retailers ignored. By focusing on these areas, Wal-Mart faced less competition and could dominate the market. Walton leveraged his company's strengths in logistics and cost management to offer lower prices, attracting customers in droves.
A good strategy also sets a proximate objective—a goal that is within reach and can be achieved with the resources at hand. It's like setting up base camps when climbing a mountain; each one is a step toward the summit, achievable and necessary for progress.
Ambitious goals are great, but without a clear path to achieve them, they're just wishful thinking. A proximate objective provides direction and keeps the team motivated with tangible milestones.
Richard Rumelt introduces the concept of the kernel, the core of any good strategy, which includes three vital components:
Before you can chart a course forward, you need to understand where you are and what challenges you face. This means taking a hard look at:
Example: IBM's Transformation
In the 1990s, IBM recognized that simply selling hardware wasn't sustainable. They diagnosed the challenge: the market was shifting toward integrated solutions and services. This understanding led them to reinvent themselves, focusing on IT services and consulting—a move that revitalized the company.
Once you've diagnosed the situation, you need a guiding policy—an overall approach that addresses the challenges you've identified.
A good guiding policy:
Example: Apple's Emphasis on Innovation
Apple's guiding policy centers on innovation and user experience. They focus on designing products that are not only functional but also beautiful and easy to use. This policy guides everything they do, from product development to marketing.
Finally, a strategy must include coherent actions—specific steps that align with your guiding policy and work together to overcome the challenges.
Coherent action means:
Example: Southwest Airlines' Operational Consistency
Southwest Airlines built its strategy around being a low-cost carrier. Their coherent actions include using a single aircraft model to simplify maintenance, operating in secondary airports to reduce fees, and turning planes around quickly at the gate. Every action supports their guiding policy of efficiency and low cost.
Just as important as knowing what makes a good strategy is understanding what constitutes a bad one. Here are some common hallmarks of bad strategy:
This is all about using fancy language and buzzwords to mask a lack of real content. It's like a sports coach giving a pep talk full of clichés but offering no real game plan.
Example: A company states, "We will leverage our core competencies to drive synergistic growth across verticals," but doesn't explain how or what that actually means.
Avoiding the real issues is a surefire way to develop a bad strategy. If a team refuses to acknowledge its weak defense, it can't create a plan to strengthen it.
Example: A retailer ignores the rise of online shopping and continues to focus solely on brick-and-mortar sales, missing out on e-commerce opportunities.
Setting ambitious goals is not the same as having a strategy. Saying "We want to be number one in our market" without outlining how to get there is like a team declaring they want to win the championship without practicing or planning.
Example: A startup aims to "disrupt the industry" but lacks a plan for product development or customer acquisition.
These are objectives that are either unrealistic or don't address the real issues. It's like a team focusing on improving their uniforms rather than their playbook.
Example: Setting a goal to "increase social media followers by 500%" without understanding how it will translate to sales or engagement.
Lehman Brothers aggressively pursued growth in the housing market without considering the mounting risks. Their failure to adapt to changing market conditions and address the underlying challenges led to their downfall during the 2008 financial crisis.
International Harvester tried to cut costs and increase market share across all divisions without addressing core operational issues. This scattershot approach failed to produce results, and the company eventually collapsed.
Chad Logan set ambitious revenue and profit targets for his graphics company without a clear understanding of the market or a plan to achieve them. His focus on end goals without a strategy to reach them exemplified bad strategy.
Despite the critical importance of good strategy, bad strategies are all too common. Here's why:
Making strategic choices often means saying no to certain opportunities, which can be uncomfortable. Leaders may avoid making tough decisions to please everyone, but in doing so, they fail to focus on what's most important.
Solution: Accept that you can't do everything. Prioritize initiatives that align with your strengths and strategic objectives.
Relying on generic templates filled with buzzwords leads to superficial strategies. It's like using a standard playbook without considering your team's unique strengths and weaknesses.
Solution: Customize your strategy based on a deep understanding of your specific situation. Avoid one-size-fits-all solutions.
Believing that ambition and positive vibes alone will lead to success ignores the need for concrete plans. It's like a team thinking they can win just by wanting it badly enough, without putting in the practice.
Solution: Pair optimism with rigorous analysis and planning. Positive thinking should inspire action, not replace it.
So how do you develop a good strategy that sets you up for success?
Whether you're leading a multinational corporation, coaching a sports team, or planning your personal goals, understanding the difference between good and bad strategy is crucial.
A good strategy doesn't guarantee success, but it significantly increases your chances by providing a clear path forward. It helps you make the most of your resources, adapt to challenges, and stay focused on what truly matters.
So the next time you set out to achieve a goal, ask yourself:
By thoughtfully considering these questions, you'll be well on your way to crafting a strategy that can make a real difference.
Take a moment to reflect on your current strategies—be it in business, sports, or personal endeavors. Are they well-defined and actionable, or are they just lofty goals without a plan? Challenge yourself to apply the principles of good strategy outlined here and watch how it transforms your approach and results.
References: